Author Topic: Gluten-free is a costly and often unneeded alternative.  (Read 10720 times)

Offline timfulford

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 99
    • View Profile
    • ATamorecreations
Re: Gluten-free is a costly and often unneeded alternative.
« Reply #15 on: March 28, 2011, 09:11:20 pm »
It is a pity that some people are willing to believe anything spoken by some celebrity types.

These are seldom well-informed people, and far to often they are eager to get their names and faces out on the airwaves anyway they can and happily accept money for "endorsements" for things that they don't really use.

On one local TV channel they have a show that purports to be about "news" for health, nutrition, exercise and so on. 
Some of the so-called celebs that have appeared on this show certainly do not practice what they preach. 
They advise people who are trying to lose weight to take questionable "herbal" products - unproved "teas" and so on, while later that evening they are caught on camera at some trendy joint, eating stuff that is the total opposite of their pitch.

I don't trust anyone who wears a size zero, has a bust that is obviously manufactured and yet says they eat a "carefully balanced diet an takes the "supplements" that they are selling.  No way!

One of the Britney Spears lookalikes that has shown up on some of these "shows" does advocate a gluten-free diet but was recently photographed chowing down at Pinks, a famous hot dog place that is certainly a long, long way from GF. 
Thousands of little girls, who should be eating a truly good, balanced diet, are doing all the wrong things because their idols tell them to buy these products. 
It's just really sad.   
And it can eventually be bad for people who actually do have the condition because it gets to the point that most people won't believe it.

I don't know if any of your remember the era of "hypoglycemia" some forty years ago, when any symptoms were attributed to this phantom low blood sugar thing.  They blamed everything from PMS to migranes on "hypoglycemia" and it went on for a few years until it was finally buried under tons of real research that proved it was all a myth. 
Bob Cummings, the actor, made a ton of money selling a "supplement" to alleviate the symptoms of hypoglycemia - sugar pills - and eventually he was sued and lost a big chunk of money in fines. 

I have to disagree about your statement about low blood sugar and its relation to migraines. As a long term sufferer of 'real' migraines not just a basic headache. Low blood sugar can and does cause migraine.

If I wake up with a migraine the last thing I want to do is eat something, however if I force myself to eat something sweet like a biscuit or better still half a dozen marsh mallows the migraine goes within an hour. If I leave it I will spend from sunrise to sunset in a darkened room being violently sick. Migraines in our family are related to low sugar levels and to the phases of the moon! We have physical evidence of this going back about fifty years.

Mr Cummings got into trouble for making claims with out the research to back it up, thus he was rightly fined.

A balanced diet is vital in a healthy life and for healthy well being. Cutting out of our natural diet items which we were designed to eat is misguided, just a eating 'junk food' or totally eating one type of food because it is not a balanced diet.

Using a TM and creating a balanced set of menus is probably the best thing you can do for your family and its fun!

Cook with all your heart and then friends and family will not be far away

Offline andiesenji

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1536
    • View Profile
    • Books, Cooks, Gadgets and Gardening
Re: Gluten-free is a costly and often unneeded alternative.
« Reply #16 on: March 28, 2011, 11:25:02 pm »
This is interesting.  When My DS was 2 he looked like a starving 3rd world baby.  He was so skinny and had this huge distended tummy.  He was a fussy eater and would hardly eat a bite after lunch.  He had problems with his bowels and got sick very easily and had enlarged tonsils and snored so loudly we could hear him 3 rooms away!! I really wanted to avoid him having any surgery and we took him to a Naturopath who suggested that we take him off not just wheat but gluten.  I was horrified and wondered how I was going to manage without gluten in his diet (this was btm - before Thermomix).  We did no testing as it involved a general ansethtic.  When I finally came around to going gluten free I was astonished as to the change in him.  He put on weight, his bowels inproved, his tonsils shrunk and he stopped snoring.  His energy levelled out (before he was a little hyperactive).  We very very strict for the first 2 years and whenever we slipped up he would get sick.  I thought it could be celliacs disease, but slowly we tried to reintroduce gluten into his diet and now he can tolerate lots of differnt grains, but he still seems to be sensitive to wheat.  Every now and again he might OD on gluten products and need to go gluten free for a while until he feels better, but it really doesn't seem so hard now.  Thankfully he seems to find spelt is fine for him so I make any cakes with this and pizza doughs etc.  It is so much easier to be gluten free with a TM.  So for my ds I think it is more of an intolerance rather than celliacs.    
actually earth mumma the only way you can know that is via the blood test and the biopsy, and he needs to be eating sufficient gluten for those to work. natropaths who suggest removing off gluten without proper medical testing make me furious. did you know that some people have NO symptoms yet still have coeliac disease? so not having much of a reaction means nothing. did you know that people with coeliac disease who consume gluten put themselves at risk of bowel cancer?  so it really is worth knowing for sure...
this is a great document that explains it all http://www.coeliacsociety.com.au/downloads/Sept%2008%20Making%20Sense%20of%20your%20diagnosis.pdf



Excellent information, Brazen.   
My point is that there is absolutely NO QUESTION that some people do have intolerance to gluten, and it can range from mild to severe but one has to be tested and the syndrome diagnosed by a medical professional, NOT someone who has a monetary impetus for convincing people to buy into this.

My daughter and two of her children have no problems with gluten but do have problems with GMO corn - and this stuff is so widespread in the food industry that it is difficult to avoid it in any prepared foods.  Even some foods labeled "natural" contain "Modified Food Starch" or GMO corn.

Since I have been happily consuming corn in all its manifestations for my entire life, I was surprised that she had this problem but it was diagnosed by her allergist after some exhaustive tests.  The symptoms are similar to lactose intolerance and also to regional ileitis but not as severe and she had been advised to undergo treatment for that before she had further tests.  Just avoiding that particular component in foods means no symptoms.   It's difficult because the stuff "hides" everywhere, even in some dairy products.  It's cheap and extends more expensive foods and is a preservative to extend shelf life.

While I don't trust all medical professionals, because some have been proven to be more or less shady characters that show up in the news from time to time.  I do trust those who are board certified and have been in practice for a long time and aren't trying to sell me something.  I will not use a physician who has an interest in a pharmacy, laboratory or physical therapy center and certainly not one who is in business to sell vitamins and nutritional supplements.  I can buy just about anything online and much cheaper. 

Today's 3:p.m. news just had a segment about a doctor in San Diego who was selling potassium iodide for $120.00 for 100 caps.  This is many times the usual cost, the stuff is dirt cheap but because of the fear of radiation from Japan, he is making a fortune.  And this is not illegal, at least not yet.  Taking this stuff can be detrimental if you are not exposed to radiation and we certainly are not.  Fear mongering should be made a federal crime, in my opinion. 
I'm not OverWeight, I'm UnderTall!
My Blog: http://www.asenjigalblogs.com/

Offline cookie1

  • Global Moderator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 37603
    • View Profile
Re: Gluten-free is a costly and often unneeded alternative.
« Reply #17 on: March 29, 2011, 01:15:44 am »
Today's 3:p.m. news just had a segment about a doctor in San Diego who was selling potassium iodide for $120.00 for 100 caps.  This is many times the usual cost, the stuff is dirt cheap but because of the fear of radiation from Japan, he is making a fortune.  And this is not illegal, at least not yet.  Taking this stuff can be detrimental if you are not exposed to radiation and we certainly are not.  Fear mongering should be made a federal crime, in my opinion. 

That is dreadful Andie. How awful that people will profit from the fear of others.
Mindmapper that is interesting re the low blood sugar and migraines. Fortunately at this stage of our lives none of us have any major intolerances. Since having the TMX I have used a lot of grains that I would not have used before. I'm pleased aboout this as it can only be good for us.
May all dairy items in your fridge be of questionable vintage.

https://www.facebook.com/The-Retired-Thermomixer-834601623316983/